Testament of Youth: Dying in the Trenches

Though Vera talks much of her suffering in waiting for news about Roland, the center of the pain and evidence of the war's effects is found in Roland's letters to Vera. In his descriptions of the trenches in "Learning Versus Life", part 13, he says "The dug-outs have been nearly all blown in, the wire entanglements are a wreck, and in among the chaos of twisted iron and splintered timber and shapeless earth are the fleshless, blackened bones of simple men who poured out their red, sweet wine of youth unknowing, for nothing more tangible than Honour or their Country's Glory or another's Lust of Power. Let him who thinks War is a glorious, golden thing, who loves to roll forth stirring words of exhortation, invoking Honour and Praise and Valour and Love of Country with as thoughtless and fervid a faith as inspired the priests..." This particular recounting caught my attention because I realized THIS was the correspondence between two young people in love. These were the kinds of letters they sent. There seems to be very little fervid romance and instead, tragedy and pain and practicality. Even their engagement seems somewhat practical and pragmatic rather than romantic. I realize this is a society still relatively fresh out of the Victorian Era, but I feel that the war has stolen the fire from these young people's hearts and crushed their romance, replacing it with a calculating, strained relationship based on letters about death, decay, and sadness. Even Vera's choice to become a nurse was a masochistic decision, made only because she knew Roland was suffering and felt ridiculous living a comfortable life during such terrible times.

Comments

I strongly agree with your comment about how "war has stolen the fire from these young people's hearts," and I felt very similarly when I was reading it as well.  In considering Vera's decision to become a nurse, I often wondered to myself if she still would have made the decision if she had not known anyone in the war.

Please remember to tag your posts with authors, titles, genres, and subjects that you write about (i.e. Vera Brittain, Testament of Youth, Memoir, Disillusionment). These will build an index for readers of the site to navigate.

Do you think it's possible to see Vera's decision to nurse as an act of solidarity, of love?

This is a very important passage to draw our attention to, because it captures much of the disillusionment that the the war poetry deals with. Wilfred Owen's "Dulce et Decorum Est" draws on a Roman motto meaning "how sweet and just it is to die for one's country" to express the exact sentiment that Roland unleashes in your quote. There is another poem about priests that I will bring to class tomorrow. Thanks for the reminder.

In reply to your question, Dr. Drouin, I do think it is possible to see Vera's decision to go into nursing as an act of solidarity. While it's true that she wasn't directly helping Roland, I'd imagine that she desperately wanted to do something. She couldn't just sit around while someone she loved was off risking his life, so she helped in the best way she knew how. On the other hand, perhaps her desire to serve as a nurse was merely her way of responding to the sentimental patriotism that gripped England during WWI. Again, I'm sure she didn't want to sit around doing nothing, but maybe her primary motivation was to help the country as a whole, rather than one specific person. 

 I also agree with the idea that the war crushed the youth and romance of the youth. I believe this was caused by the fact the youth of the war had their own budding identities crushed and reformed into an identity only sculpted by their wartime occupations. As opposed to most other modern generations,  the young generation of World War I was not given time to cultivate their own identities and were doomed to be lost without one.